$1,500,000
2 bd3 ba2,238 sq ft · House for sale
4333 SEMINOLE Street, Starke, FL 32091
On Kingsley Lake
Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER SMITH AND SMITH REALTY
If you’re searching for Kingsley Lake waterfront homes for sale, you’re looking at one of the most rare and desirable lakefront markets in Northeast Florida.
Located near Starke, Florida and within reach of Jacksonville, Kingsley Lake is famous for its perfect circular shape, crystal-clear water, and private waterfront living—making it a top choice for buyers seeking true lakefront property (not retention ponds or canals).
Scroll below to view available listings, pricing trends, and everything you need to know before buying.
$1,500,000
2 bd3 ba2,238 sq ft · House for sale
On Kingsley Lake
Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER SMITH AND SMITH REALTY
Kingsley Lake isn’t just another lake—it’s a high-demand, low-inventory waterfront market.
The Kingsley Lake market is tight and competitive due to limited waterfront supply.
Important:
Unlike cookie-cutter neighborhoods, Kingsley Lake values are driven by frontage, depth, and view—not just square footage.

Living on Kingsley Lake offers a completely different lifestyle than standard Florida neighborhoods:
This is “legacy property” territory—homes people keep for decades.
If inventory is limited, you may also want to explore:
Buying a lakefront home is NOT the same as buying a regular house.
You need to understand:
With 20+ years of construction experience and 18+ years in Florida real estate, I help buyers:
Looking for Kingsley Lake waterfront homes for sale in Florida?
I can help you:
Call or text: 904-562-9345
Email: mike@904HomeStore.com
Is Kingsley Lake a good place to buy a waterfront home?
Yes—Kingsley Lake is one of Florida’s most unique lakes with limited inventory and strong long-term value.
Are there docks allowed on Kingsley Lake?
Yes, most waterfront homes include private docks, but regulations vary.
How deep is Kingsley Lake?
Kingsley Lake reaches depths of around 90–100 feet, making it ideal for boating and recreation.
How far is Kingsley Lake from Jacksonville?
Approximately 45–60 minutes depending on location
Mike Schwiebert is a REALTOR® with INI Realty INC serving Kingsley Lake. Licensed since 2007. Voted Best of Clay 2019 and 2020 (Clay Today). Voted Best of Jax Top 5 2019 (Folio). Lake Asbury resident since 2009. Client reviews on Google, Facebook, Zillow and Realtor.com. Call or text 904-562-9345. See Mike's track record.
Be first to know when a home that fits comes on the market.
Complimentary trailer use for clients buying or selling with Mike Schwiebert, INI Realty INC. Subject to availability; terms apply.