Facebook Twitter Youtube
904homestore Logo Get More Value with the Best Realtor

Keystone Heights Homes for Sale

🏡 Keystone Heights, FL Homes for Sale

Small-Town Charm, Lakeside Living & Outdoor Lifestyle in Clay County

Welcome to Keystone Heights, Florida — a peaceful, nature-rich community offering lakefront living, spacious lots, and a relaxed small-town atmosphere. Nestled in southwest Clay County, Keystone Heights is known for its spring-fed lakes, rolling terrain, rural feel, and friendly community vibe, making it a perfect escape from busy city life — while still within commuting distance to Jacksonville, Gainesville, and Middleburg. You will love Keystone Heights Homes and the variety of styles and lakefront living.

If you’re looking for affordable lakefront property, room to breathe, and a true Old-Florida lifestyle, Keystone Heights may be the perfect place to call home. See more details below.

Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
Save Search

295 BEREA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2134382

295 BEREA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
49Picture(s)
2,236Sqft
A truly unique home almost completely surrounded by Lake Brooklyn! This property has exceptional curb appeal! Vaulted ceilings, wooden beams, fireplace, two primary suites and three full baths make this comfortable home a place you will never want to leave! Featuring lakefront on three sides, a center kitchen and tons of windows that allow plenty of natural light.
$1,500,000

5040 SAGEBRUSH, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2133886

5040 SAGEBRUSH, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
73Picture(s)
2,308Sqft
Welcome to a custom Cypress D-log home situated on 10.18 beautiful acres, with 5 fully fenced and cross-fenced acres ready for horses or livestock. This one-of-a-kind property offers privacy, quality construction, and a true North Florida country lifestyle.
$985,000

7120 GAS LINE, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2120440

7120 GAS LINE, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
82Picture(s)
3,637Sqft
LAKEFRONT ** SALTWATER POOL ** ACREAGE ** Escape to luxury with this stunning 3700 sqft waterfront home on Loch Lommond. Boasting over160ft of shoreline on over 3 private acres, this 5928 sq ft home offers the ultimate in privacy and upscale living. The spacious upper level features a custom kitchen with maple cabinets, a breakfast bar, and an open living area with 10' ceilings.
$775,000

561 LAKEVIEW, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2088260

561 LAKEVIEW, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

5Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
37Picture(s)
3,068Sqft
This LAKEFRONT HOME also has a pool, spa, deck and checks every box! This move in ready home has vintage charm with modern versatility. The park like setting is located on Lake Geneva, one of the most prestigious lakes in Keystone Heights! This desirable location in the heart of town gives you walking access to Keystone Beach, parks, shopping and restaurants plus ''A'' rated schools.
$699,500

5824 JONES CREEK, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2137786

5824 JONES CREEK, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
20Picture(s)
1,520Sqft
Country living at it's finest! Charming and rustic home tucked back on almost ten acres of fenced in beauty! Across from Belmore State Forest. Pastures, Creek, Small Pond, pens, tack room, barn with two stalls and a garden area. Shed/workshop with lean to as well as RV/equipment covered carport. Wood deck with Stone fireplace/grill for all of your out door BBQ pleasure.
$650,000

6455 BROOKLYN BAY, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2135429

6455 BROOKLYN BAY, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
50Picture(s)
2,508Sqft
Custom built and well loved by one owner! Oversized corner lot with additional one acre included. Spacious kitchen with breakfast nook and eat at counter. Formal dining room adjoins the large living room. Near the kitchen/living areas are French doors to the large FL room which overlooks the private back yard.
$599,900

7550 MONONGAHELA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2124630

7550 MONONGAHELA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
36Picture(s)
2,564Sqft
Welcome to this brand-new 2026 construction situated on over an acre of land, No HOA! This thoughtfully designed 4-bedroom, 2.5 bath home features, LVP Flooring throughout. Tile in bathrooms. Frameless enclosed master shower, Quarts counter tops, custom-built pantry. 32x36 oversized garage and a spacious covered back porch, Flood Lights and irrigation front and back. Privacy, and modern comfort.
$598,000

49 NELSONS POINT, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2120466

49 NELSONS POINT, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
39Picture(s)
2,926Sqft
This 3 bedroom (potential 4 bedroom), 3 full bath, 2926 SF waterfront, mid-century, brick, US Steel ranch, located on Lake Geneva. A 1000 SF permitted addition in 1999, with bricked exterior to match the rest of home.
$584,900

6441 BAKER, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2114207

6441 BAKER, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
66Picture(s)
2,586Sqft
This immaculate and well loved lake home with additional cottage and a 20x20 detached garage plus 20x20 RV/Boat port on coveted Lake Hutchinson has it all!!! Updates include a new well with filter system (2023), 26 gauge Galvalume industrial metal roof, surge generator hook up, wood decks, etc.
$561,900

MLS 2127418

5893 WHITE SANDS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
5Picture(s)
2,037Sqft
WATERFRONT WITH A GUEST HOUSE!!! Discover the pinnacle of lakeside living in this stunningly remodeled two-story concrete block home situated directly on White Sands Lake. This property features a main residence and a guest house set on a spacious 0.79-acre lot with 80 feet of water frontage.
$550,000

7634 AZTEC, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2100739

7634 AZTEC, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
33Picture(s)
2,653Sqft
$514,900 +$20k towards new roof & $5k flooring allowance! Fully Handicap accessible! Oasis. a stunning gated home that offers everything you need for luxury living and peaceful relaxation. Enjoy your own heated swimming pool with a waterfall, a full rear deck overlooking lush landscaping, and even lake views.
$514,900

6490 WOODLAND, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2102131

6490 WOODLAND, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
56Picture(s)
2,702Sqft
LAKEFRONT BEAUTY! This amazing lakefront home offers the perfect blend of charm, comfort, and convenience—just minutes from town and zoned for great schools. Step into the spacious, open floorplan...the updated kitchen has lovely white cabinetry, nice counters, and SS appliances.
$499,900
72 Results returned.Per Page

🌟 Why Buyers Love Keystone Heights Homes

  • Beautiful spring-fed lakes & waterfront homes

  • Larger lots & acreage properties

  • Peaceful country lifestyle with charming downtown

  • Boating, kayaking, fishing & nature everywhere

  • Quick drive to Middleburg, Gainesville & Starke

  • Close-knit, community-focused living

  • Lower property taxes and strong affordability

Keystone Heights offers small-town Florida living with big outdoor adventure.

🏠 Homes in Keystone Heights

You’ll find a wide range of housing styles and land options, including:

  • Lakefront homes on Lake Geneva, Lake Brooklyn & more

  • Homes with acreage & wooded lots

  • Country estates & ranch homes

  • Modern builds & remodeled homes

  • Manufactured & modular homes on land

  • New construction opportunities

  • Affordable starter homes & investment options

Whether you’re seeking a homestead, a lakefront retreat, or peaceful rural living, Keystone Heights delivers.

🌳 Lifestyle & Amenities

Life in Keystone Heights centers around outdoor living, nature, and community, including:

  • Parks & lakefront beaches

  • Community golf course

  • Public boat ramps & fishing areas

  • Hiking, horseback riding & bike trails

  • Camp Blanding & vast natural preserves nearby

  • Sports and recreation at Keystone Beach & city parks

This is North Florida living at its purest — quiet, scenic, and full of open skies.

🏫 Schools & Area Services

Served by the Clay County School District, Keystone Heights offers:

  • Keystone Heights Elementary

  • Keystone Heights Jr/Sr High School

  • Nearby private & charter school options

  • Local library, community center & city services

A charming small-town setting with supportive community values.

🧭 Local Real Estate Expert Advantage

As a Clay County Realtor®, Lake Asbury resident, and former custom builder, I help you:

✅ Compare acreage, lakefront & neighborhood options
✅ Understand well/septic systems & rural utilities
✅ Evaluate construction quality & renovation potential
✅ Identify future growth & value opportunities
✅ Secure land for new builds or homesteads

Whether you’re relocating, retiring, investing, or looking for quiet country-lake living, I’ve got Keystone Heights covered.

🔎 Start Your Keystone Heights Home Search

Let’s find the perfect home or lakefront property:

📲 Call/Text: 904-562-9345
🌐 Search Keystone Heights Homes: 904HomeStore.com

Tell me what you’re looking for — I’ll curate a custom list just for you.

 

Voted Best Real Estate Agent 2019 in Clay County!

 

  • Keystone Heights FL homes for sale

  • Keystone Heights real estate

  • Lakefront homes Keystone Heights FL

  • Keystone Heights land & acreage

  • Clay County rural homes

  • Lake Geneva homes for sale FL

  • North Florida country living