Your Guide to Buying & Selling Real Estate in Starke, FL

If you’re searching for homes for sale in Starke Florida, you’ll find a unique blend of rural charm, small-town living, and affordable Florida real estate options. Starke offers everything from cozy starter homes to farm properties, horse-friendly acreage, waterfront homes on Kingsley Lake,Crystal Lake, Sampson Lake, and investment opportunities that continue to grow as Northeast Florida expands.

As a highly reviewed Northeast Florida REALTOR® with 18+ years of real estate experience and 20+ years in the construction industry, I help buyers and sellers throughout Bradford County Get More Value from their real estate decisions. If you’re looking for the best REALTOR® in Starke, Florida, my hands-on construction knowledge and proven marketing strategies give you an unmatched advantage.

Sort Option
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
Save Search

346 CHERRY, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2078238

346 CHERRY, Starke, Florida 32091

5Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
65Picture(s)
2,718Sqft
Ready for some rental income or want to transform this Victorian home to it's original glory….you've got options! This Amazing Victorian historic home from 1930 is located on a quiet brickstone street in the heart of historic Starke! Options gallore…change zoning and make inprovements or Bed/Breakfast, or use as a multi-generational home.
$320,000

312 MARKET, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2118270

312 MARKET, Starke, Florida 32091

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
51Picture(s)
1,092Sqft
Renovated all brick home on 0.
$315,000

6935 CR 233, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2113336

6935 CR 233, Starke, Florida 32091

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
40Picture(s)
1,525Sqft
5 Acres & a BRAND NEW, FURNISHED Manufactured Home! Welcome home to this stunning property perfectly set on 5 beautiful acres! The possibilities here are truly endless. Power poles are already placed throughout the entire property, making it easy to add a workshop, guest home, or whatever your heart desires.
$314,000

403 CHERRY, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2058680

403 CHERRY, Starke, Florida 32091

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
41Picture(s)
2,299Sqft
Open house Saturday 7/26 2-5 pm REDUCED 25,000.00. Now 300,000.00. Step back in time with this unique property in Starke, steeped in history and charm! While seller information suggests the home may have been originally built in 1869, courthouse records date it to 1940, with additional updates in 1960. Full details can be found in the seller's disclosure.
$300,000

15904 15TH, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2099767

15904 15TH, Starke, Florida 32091

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
22Picture(s)
1,756Sqft
Sellers are motivated!! This 2 story, 4-bedroom, 2-bath home is nestled in an area near the Starke Golf & Country Club. With a two-year-old metal roof, windows installed in May 2024, water heater replaced in 2021, many big-ticket items are already in place. In addition there is a bathroom on each floor, attached garage and a fenced area for pets.
$299,900

403 WALNUT, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2061233

403 WALNUT, Starke, Florida 32091

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
54Picture(s)
4,551Sqft
Assumable Mortgage at 2.6%! NEW HVAC unit installed 06/2025! Beautiful Historic Home in the Heart of Downtown Starke. Step into a piece of history with this stunning 4,551 sq. ft. home, located on a spacious 1/2-acre lot. This timeless beauty boasts 4 generously sized bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms.
$290,000

15049 75TH, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2092092

15049 75TH, Starke, Florida 32091

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
75Picture(s)
1,286Sqft
Discover your dream home in this stunning 2023 residence located directly across from Sampson Lake, one of the largest lakes in the area, renowned for its excellent fishing and recreational opportunities.
$275,000

680 MADISON, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2103865

680 MADISON, Starke, Florida 32091

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
75Picture(s)
2,073Sqft
WELCOME HOME to this 105 year old charmer!!! This beauty has serious curb appeal with pretty landscaping, mature trees & an inviting front door. Once inside, you'll be greeted by a cozy reading nook (or your future home office), followed by a spacious living room with stunning hardwood floors & a beautiful fireplace.
$267,499

18894 STATE ROUTE 16, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2102239

18894 STATE ROUTE 16, Starke, Florida 32091

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
33Picture(s)
1,248Sqft
Holding the charm of many original features- this all block home has been lovingly maintained over the years. This yard is one of its greatest attributes- the back is fenced, concrete driveway splits it as a ''double lot'' with a concrete pad and rv hookups The 16×40 barn has served as a home gym and man cave. Inside has a huge master suite which could also serve as a large family room.
$265,000

822 PRATT, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2084627

822 PRATT, Starke, Florida 32091

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
55Picture(s)
1,676Sqft
*NEW metal roof* Sitting on a rare 0.75-acre double lot in the heart of Starke, this charming mid-century home blends vintage character with practical updates. Step inside to find 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, original parquet floors, and colorful retro tile that adds personality throughout.
$259,900

145 ORANGE, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2114470

145 ORANGE, Starke, Florida 32091

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
42Picture(s)
1,966Sqft
WELCOME HOME to this adorable bungalow located in the heart of Starke with 4 bedrooms & 3 full bathrooms. 145 N Orange St offers updated flooring, a cozy fireplace, a beautiful kitchen, formal dining room, extra large laundry room, and a private oasis in the backyard.
$259,900

8505 137TH, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2113329

8505 137TH, Starke, Florida 32091

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
24Picture(s)
1,440Sqft
BACK ON THE MARKET AT NO FAULT TO SELLER!! Beautiful 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Home on Sampson Lake! Experience lakefront living at its finest with this stunning waterfront property, perfect for endless summer fun, peaceful mornings, and making memories that last a lifetime. Nestled on a quiet, cleared lot, this home offers both tranquility and adventure.
$250,000
36 Results returned.Per Page
Homes for sale in starke florida with the best realtor MIke Schwiebert

Why Buyers Love Living in Starke, FL

Starke is one of North Florida’s most desirable rural communities thanks to:

✔ Affordable home prices compared to Clay and Duval
✔ Large lots, acreage, and privacy
✔ Proximity to Gainesville, Middleburg, and Jacksonville
✔ Strong sense of community
✔ Great for horses, farming, and outdoor living
✔ Lakefront and fishing-friendly neighborhoods

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, relocating to Bradford County, or looking for more land, Starke offers incredible value.

 

Starke, Florida Real Estate Options

🏡 Single-Family Homes

Traditional homes in established neighborhoods such as Starke Heights, Deerwood, and Downtown Starke.

🌳 Acreage & Country Estates

Perfect for farming, homesteading, workshops, and outdoor living.

🐎 Horse Properties & Agricultural Land

Starke is known for large tracts of land, barns, pasture-ready acreage, and equestrian-friendly zoning.

🌊 Waterfront Homes

Beautiful lakefront homes on:

  • Kingsley Lake (nearby)

  • Sampson Lake

  • Crystal Lake

  • Crosby Lake

💼 Starke Investment Properties

Duplexes, mobile homes on land, rental-ready units, and flips.

Starke FL Home Search

Popular searches:

  • Starke homes under $300,000

  • Starke homes on acreage

  • Starke waterfront homes

  • Starke horse properties

  • Starke new construction

  • Starke investment homes

 

Why I’m One of the Best REALTORS® in Starke, Florida

Experience. Integrity. Construction Knowledge. Results.

When you buy or sell a home in Starke, you need a REALTOR® who understands land, septic systems, wells, drainage, structural integrity, and rural property requirements.

I provide:

✔ 20+ years of construction expertise

I identify issues before you spend money on inspections and help you understand the value of land, foundation condition, roofing, electrical, well/septic, and more.

✔ 18+ years as a licensed Florida REALTOR®

Proven negotiation skills and deep knowledge of Bradford County and surrounding areas.

✔ No long-term listing contracts

I earn your business through performance, not paperwork.

✔ Free moving trailer, dump trailer & pressure washing rigs for clients

Saving you money and stress before listing or after buying.

✔ Aggressive multi-platform marketing

Your listing will appear across Zillow, Realtor.com, MLS, social media, video marketing, and targeted ads.

✔ Honest, straightforward guidance

I treat every transaction with fairness, transparency, and integrity.

If you’re searching for the best REALTOR® in Starke, FL, my background gives you a decisive advantage.

Thinking of Selling Your Home in Starke?

Get a free, no-pressure property valuation backed by real construction insight and real market data.

I help sellers maximize their returns through:

  • Pre-listing repair recommendations

  • Optional upfront repair assistance

  • Professional marketing & photography

  • Starke-specific pricing strategies

Your home deserves top-dollar — I’ll help you get it.

Ready to Buy or Sell in Starke, Florida?

Let’s talk about your goals and create a plan that gets you More Value.

📱 Call/Text: 904-562-9345
🌐 904HomeStore.com
📧 [email protected]
🏡 Mike Schwiebert, REALTOR® – INI Realty