Facebook Twitter Youtube
Get More Value with the best realtor

Homes for Sale in lake butler

Homes for Sale in Lake Butler – Real-Time Listings & Expert Real Estate Guidance

Searching for homes for sale in Lake Butler, Florida? Welcome to 904HomeStore.com — your trusted real estate resource for the newest Lake Butler FL real estate listings, neighborhood insights, and professional guidance from an experienced North Florida REALTOR® with over 18 years of experience and 20+ years in construction and home evaluation.

Whether you’re buying your first home, relocating, upgrading, or investing, this page gives you instant access to the most accurate Lake Butler homes currently on the market.

Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
Save Search

21400 NW COUNTY ROAD 235, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2112933

21400 NW COUNTY ROAD 235, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
12Picture(s)
2,957Sqft
MULTIPLE PARCELS! Nice brick home on 7 acres with adjacent 40 acres, and 71 acres to be sold ALL together. The house has open floor plan, nice size kitchen, and fruit trees. There is a room with it's own bathroom in the garage making this a 4 bedroom home. The 40 acres is partly cleared. Buyer to do due diligence on all the properties.
$1,384,990

15971 64TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2107494

15971 64TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
46Picture(s)
2,721Sqft
This stunning custom home offers the perfect blend of peaceful country living with convenient access to Jacksonville's shopping, dining, and entertainment. Nestled on a beautiful 1-acre lot in the Lake Butler area, you'll love the sense of space, privacy, and charm that surrounds you.
$569,900

580 3RD, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2129929

580 3RD, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
61Picture(s)
2,014Sqft
WELCOME HOME to this beautifully renovated 4 bedroom, 3 full bathroom home offering timeless Southern charm and modern updates. Located on approx. 1.19 fully fenced acres in the heart of Lake Butler, this move-in ready home blends a welcoming, cozy feel with spacious living areas designed for comfort and functionality.
$364,900

220 3RD, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2130414

220 3RD, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
41Picture(s)
1,232Sqft
Charming Home in the heart of Lake Butler, FL. Located within the city limits of Lake Butler, this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers comfort, convenience, and small-town charm. The thoughtfully designed layout includes a nice size island for family dinner and featuring a nice walk-in shower, energy efficient low E vinyl windows.
$320,000

4881 136TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2123114

4881 136TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
26Picture(s)
1,580Sqft
Welcome to this 3BR/2BA home on a spacious 1.7-acre parcel in Worthington Springs. The perfect blend of modern comfort and country living! Bright, open living spaces and tasteful finishes create a welcoming atmosphere throughout.
$275,000

160 9TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2126828

160 9TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
24Picture(s)
1,696Sqft
This sale INCLUDES the neighboring property 170 SW 9th Avenue, a 3-bedroom 2 bath mobile home on 0.45 acres already producing income! Total lot size for both properties 0.81 Acres. The main property has Great opportunity to add value! This 4-bedroom, 2-bath home needs work and is ideal for a buyer looking for a fixer-upper.
$272,000

5608 COUNTY ROAD 240, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2133742

5608 COUNTY ROAD 240, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
27Picture(s)
948Sqft
Country cottage situated on 8 mostly wooded acres in Union County. Over 800 ft of paved road frontage with a dry bed creek behind the house. Circle driveway, 2 detached carports, fruit trees. Home features include split bedroom arrangement, 2 full baths, electric fireplace, large covered front porch. All sorts of wildlife on this wooded parcel of land.
$250,000

5671 56TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2118993

5671 56TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
45Picture(s)
1,512Sqft
***LIMITED TIME INCENTIVE SO ACT QUICK – Seller is offering $10,000 to buyer towards closing costs or rate buy down with acceptable offer before 3/8!*** Welcome home to this 4 bedroom 2 bathroom home on just under 2.5 acres.
$210,000

11830 45TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054 MLS 2126812

11830 45TH, Lake Butler, Florida 32054

2Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
16Picture(s)
924Sqft
Well maintained 1994 singlewide on half acre. 2 bedrooms, 1 bath. Could be a rental income or personal property. Conveniently located between Lake City, Gainesville, Lake Butler and Starke, making it a breeze to run errands, pick up dinner, with an abundance of entertainment choices.
$89,900
    9 Results returned.Per Page

     

    🏡 Search Lake Butler FL Homes for Sale in Real Time

    Explore current MLS listings including:

    ✔ Single-family homes
    ✔ New construction properties
    ✔ Country homes & large lots
    ✔ Land & acreage
    ✔ Investment opportunities

    👉 Use the live home search above to view prices, photos, and property details instantly.

     

    📍 Why Buy a Home in Lake Butler, Florida?

    Lake Butler is known for its peaceful lifestyle, affordability, and strong sense of community — making it a great choice for buyers looking for value in North Florida.

    Homebuyers appreciate Lake Butler for:

    🏡 Affordable housing options
    🌳 Spacious properties and rural charm
    🚗 Convenient access to Gainesville, Lake City & Jacksonville
    💲 Lower overall cost of living
    👨‍👩‍👧 Small-town atmosphere

    If you’re seeking space, value, and a relaxed lifestyle, Lake Butler offers excellent real estate opportunities.

     

    🤝 Work With an Experienced North Florida Real Estate Professional

    Buying a home is a major investment — and having the right REALTOR® makes all the difference.

    With my background in real estate and construction, I help you:

    ✅ Evaluate home quality and value
    ✅ Avoid costly inspection surprises
    ✅ Negotiate confidently and strategically
    ✅ Understand current market conditions
    ✅ Navigate the buying process smoothly

    You’re not just finding a home — you’re making a smart real estate decision.

     

    📈 Selling a Home in Lake Butler FL?

    Thinking about selling your property?

    I provide:

    ✔ Market-driven pricing strategies
    ✔ High-visibility online marketing
    ✔ Professional listing presentation
    ✔ Buyer exposure and targeting
    ✔ Strong negotiation to maximize value

    👉 Request a free home value analysis to learn what your Lake Butler home is worth today.

    🔍 Popular Lake Butler FL Home Search Terms

    • Homes for sale in Lake Butler FL

    • Lake Butler Florida real estate listings

    • Affordable homes in Lake Butler FL

    • New construction homes Lake Butler

    • Land for sale Lake Butler Florida

    • Union County homes for sale

    • Houses in Lake Butler FL

    • Homes for sale in Starke FL

      City of Lake Butler Website

     

    ❓ Lake Butler Homes for Sale – Buyer FAQ

     

    Are homes in Lake Butler FL affordable?

    Yes. Lake Butler typically offers more affordable home prices compared to nearby metro areas.

     

    Is Lake Butler a good place to invest in real estate?

    Yes. Lower purchase prices and continued demand for rural living make it appealing for long-term investment.

     

    Can I view Lake Butler homes for sale in real time?

    Yes! Listings on this page update directly from the MLS for the most accurate availability.

     

    Do you assist with inspections and negotiations?

    Absolutely. My construction background provides valuable insight during inspections and negotiations.

     

    📞 Start Your Lake Butler Home Search Today

    Browse homes or get expert help now.

    👉 View Lake Butler Homes for Sale
    👉 Request a Free Home Value
    👉 Contact an Experienced REALTOR®

     

    Call Mike Now

    🔑20+ Years in Construction and 18+ Years in Florida Real Estate 

    Homes for sale in Lake Butler Florida
    Send Mike a Message

    I have experience that other agents simply do not have. 

    Picture of Mike Schwiebert

    Mike Schwiebert

    Mike Schwiebert is a two-time Best of Clay Realtor Winner, multiple-time Best of Jax top 5, a home selling expert, former general, building and remodeling contractor, Investor, and girl dad. 20+ years of construction experience and 18+ years of local real estate experience.