Compare Listings

Fleming Island Homes for Sale


Are you searching for Fleming Island Homes for Sale? I would love to help you find the perfect home! Fleming Island Florida is one of the most desired neighborhoods with some of the best features in Clay County and the Orange Park area. Fleming Island has great schools, and is close to shopping, golf courses and restaurants. It is surrounded by water on all sides from Doctors Lake, the Saint Johns River and Black Creek. Many say once you are on the island you hate to leave.

Here is a little history on Fleming Island and how it came about. Click here for more info.
When you see a home you would like to see call, text or email your Realtor Mike Schwiebert at 904-562-9345.
Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
For sale

901 CREIGHTON, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 1237687

901 CREIGHTON, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Sqft: 0
Visits:
Land
Come build your DREAM HOME on one of the FEW desirable waterfront lots in Fleming Island! This lot is situated down the private, sought out Creighton Rd located just over the Doctors Lake Bridge. Included is two lots with 275 feet of frontage on Doctors Lake and has additional frontage on the canal. Bring your boat and build a custom dock because you can very easily access the Ocean and St.
$2,950,000
For sale

6935 OLD CHURCH, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2027462

6935 OLD CHURCH, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 3
Sqft: 2,950
Visits:
Residential
Once in a while, a property becomes available that it is so rare as to be unique. This outstanding estate is part of George Fleming's original 1000 acre land grant, dating from 1796, known as Hibernia. The home, named Holly cottage was constructed in 1897 and is the only remaining home of the 'Old Place' owned by the Fleming family.
$2,585,000
For sale

2075 SALT MYRTLE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2062563

2075 SALT MYRTLE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 5
Bath(s): 4
Sqft: 6,048
Visits:
Residential
Welcome to this estate waterfront home in gated Pace Island, nestled on an acre of beautifully landscaped grounds. Enjoy the 128-feet of sweeping views of Doctor's Lake or wander out to the 500-foot shared dock with a boathouse for a cocktail or morning coffee.
$2,275,000
For sale

1333 SOUTH SHORE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2068037

1333 SOUTH SHORE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 3
Sqft: 3,500
Visits:
Residential
Look at this gorgeous waterfront home! This mid-century, custom built home is nestled on a private 1.66 acre parcel. You'll love relaxing on your dock while enjoying the breathtaking views that Doctors Lake has to offer! This private dock was completely rebuilt in 2020 including the 28' by 14' boat slip. While touring this property, make sure to check out the 2 story dock house.
$2,225,000
For sale

3593 WESTOVER, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2067909

3593 WESTOVER, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 3
Sqft: 4,282
Visits:
Residential
Welcome to this stunning brick estate home, perfectly situated on 1.89 acres of prime waterfront property in the highly sought-after Fleming Island. Boasting 116 feet of navigable riverfront, this property offers the ultimate Florida lifestyle you've been dreaming of! As you enter, you'll be captivated by the soaring ceilings that create an atmosphere of elegance and grandeur.
$2,150,000
For sale

149 RIVERWOOD, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2070696

149 RIVERWOOD, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 2
Sqft: 2,911
Visits:
Residential
Come see this beautiful 4 bedroom 2.5 bath home on the St. Johns river. The living space in this home is open and the river is visible from nearly everywhere in the house. The open chefs kitchen has Bosch appliances, a beautiful fireplace, and a gorgeous backyard for entertaining your family and friends.
$1,800,000
For sale

3110 CREIGHTON LANDING, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2041828

3110 CREIGHTON LANDING, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 4
Sqft: 3,430
Visits:
Residential
Back on the Market as buyer could not perform. Welcome to your dream retreat on Doctors Lake! Whether you're an avid boater, fisher, kayaker, or simply enjoy peaceful sunsets by the pool, this stunning one-story home offers the ultimate Florida lifestyle. Situated on a sprawling half-acre+ lot with over 150 feet of bulkheaded frontage and an additional 122 feet along a tranquil canal.
$1,275,000
For sale

487 CREIGHTON, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2059014

487 CREIGHTON, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 3
Bath(s): 3
Sqft: 2,952
Visits:
Residential
Come see this beautiful 3 bedroom 3 bath waterfront pool home with 169 ft of frontage directly on Doctors Lake. This home is conveniently located on the north end of Fleming Island with easy boat access to the St Johns River. The property was built up approx. 6 ft. for additional elevation before the construction of the new home which was built in 2005.
$1,249,000
For sale

1924 HOLMES, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2039397

1924 HOLMES, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 5
Bath(s): 4
Sqft: 3,401
Visits:
Residential
Located on Doctor's Lake, and situated in a 6-home gated community, this waterfront retreat is a must see. This modern masterpiece boasts 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and a sprawling 3401 square feet of luxurious living space, all nestled on a generous 1.28 acre lot. A covered front porch welcomes you to this stunning home. French doors lead from the spacious foyer to a spacious home office.
$1,200,000
For sale

111 FAIRWAY OAKS, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2067610

111 FAIRWAY OAKS, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 4
Bath(s): 2
Sqft: 2,101
Visits:
Residential
Charming Riverfront Home on the St. John's River Located on a quiet cul-de-sac, this inviting riverfront home offers serene views of the water and stunning sunrises from the kitchen, master bedroom, living room, and pool area. Situated directly on the St. John's River—a major navigable waterway—this property is ideal for boating, fishing, and enjoying Florida's abundant wildlife.
$995,000
For sale

1926 HICKORY TRACE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2070213

1926 HICKORY TRACE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 5
Bath(s): 4
Sqft: 4,070
Visits:
Residential
Welcome to the epitome of luxury living in gated River Hills Reserve at Fleming Island Plantation! This expansive 5-bed, 4.5-bath home boasts two 2-car garages. The interior is a masterpiece of design, featuring wood tile flooring and crown molding throughout. The dining room is elegantly appointed w/hutches and custom molding.
$985,000
For sale

3461 MAINARD BRANCH, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2063160

3461 MAINARD BRANCH, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

Bed(s): 5
Bath(s): 4
Sqft: 3,321
Visits:
Residential
Stunning pool home with private boat slip, perfectly situated in the highly sought-after Daniels Landing section of Eagle Harbor. Step inside and be welcomed by soaring ceilings and breathtaking views of the backyard, complete with lush landscaping and a sparkling pool, visible through the charming French doors.
$985,000
125 Results returned.Per Page

Fleming Island Homes For Sale

Single Family Homes Or Vacant Land In Fleming Island? We Have Them Both Available!

Are you looking for a New Construction Fleming Island Home for Sale? If you are looking for a new home, or lot to build your next home in Fleming Island I would love to help you.  My knowledge of real estate and construction will help you have the best leverage at getting the best deal on your new home. If you are looking to build a new home in Fleming Island, I work with dozens of builders in town and I am sure I can refer you to a few greats ones once we talk about your needs.

Fleming Island Condos for Sale? Yeah we have them!

Condos do come up for sale in Fleming Island and we have them available. A lot of people looking for maintenance free living tend to lean towards condos so they can spend more time away from the home. Condo associations take care of the exterior maintenance which helps free up some time when you don’t have to do yard work. Check out some Fleming Island  Condos for sale here.

Junk Fees? Never!

I never charge and junk fees like other agents in the area. They may be called document storage fees, transaction fees, or other misleading terms, but I never charge them!

Fleming Island Homes for Sale Mike Schwiebert Best RealtorIf you are looking to buy or sell an Fleming Island Home you have come to the right place. I would love to help you find your next home. When you see something you like please call, text, or email me anytime and I will get to work for you. Call Mike Schwiebert Realtor at 904-562-9345. Voted Best Real Estate Agent 2019 in Clay County!

 

 

Join The Discussion