Facebook Twitter Youtube
Get More Value with the best realtor

🏡 Fleming Island Homes for Sale

Luxury Living • Top Schools • Waterfront Homes • Premier Clay County Real Estate

If you’re searching for homes for sale in Fleming Island, FL, you’re looking at one of the most desirable communities in Clay County and all of Northeast Florida. With top-rated schools, golf course communities, beautiful waterfront homes, family-friendly neighborhoods, and easy access to Jacksonville, Fleming Island offers a lifestyle that appeals to families, retirees, professionals, and investors alike.

I’m Mike Schwiebert, REALTOR® with 18+ years of experience and 20+ years in construction, helping buyers and sellers throughout Fleming Island get more value from every real estate transaction. Whether you’re interested in Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, Fleming Island Plantation, or a luxury Doctors Lake waterfront home — I’m here to help.

Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
Save Search

2260 HARBOR LAKE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2129274

2260 HARBOR LAKE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
56Picture(s)
2,626Sqft
Welcome home to this bright and beautiful home in the heart of Eagle Harbor! Ideally located within walking distance to the elementary school, parks, Doctors Lake and the golf club, this home offers the perfect blend of convenience and community. Step inside to an open and airy floor plan featuring a spacious kitchen with an island, abundant counter space and a secondary seating bar.
$2,800

1591 SHELTER COVE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2116928

1591 SHELTER COVE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
26Picture(s)
1,881Sqft
Wonderfully renovated open ranch plan with four bedrooms, two baths, very large bedrooms (suitable for queen or king bedroom sets), bountiful natural light & lovely pond view. The broad pocket sliders provide for access to the covered & screened lanai. The vaulted ceiling soars to at least 16ft in height. Both bathrooms to be fully renovated as well.
$2,775

1630 MAJESTIC VIEW, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2122368

1630 MAJESTIC VIEW, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
29Picture(s)
2,347Sqft
Available immediately this Fleming Island Plantation 4/3 home features fresh paint, hardwood floors and new carpet. The primary bedroom & 2 additional bedrooms plus private office are located on the 1st floor & a large 4th bedroom & bath are upstairs perfect for teenager or a quiet retreat. The kitchen features Granite countertops, ample cabinets, storage & an island.
$2,750

1604 BRIGHTON BLUFF, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2131980

1604 BRIGHTON BLUFF, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
50Picture(s)
2,080Sqft
Beautiful Eagle Harbor home for rent!! Homes sits at the end of the cul-de-sac on a beautiful lot! Open floor plan with ceramic tile and wood floors throughout! Many decorative touches throughout. Newer appliances and granite countertops in kitchen. AT&T fiber installed throughout the home. Nice screened in patio off the backside of the house.
$2,550

1563 LAKEWAY, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2130106

1563 LAKEWAY, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
73Picture(s)
2,893Sqft
Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom rental in Fleming Island, where comfort, space, and resort-style amenities come together. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the spacious covered front porch, the perfect place to relax and unwind.
$2,500

1800 CASTILLE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2126013

1800 CASTILLE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
30Picture(s)
1,990Sqft
Available: Now! Welcome to your own slice of Fleming Island paradise. This brick beauty sits in the quiet, well-loved Oak Creek community, where the streets are calm, the yards are generous, and coming home actually feels like a reset.
$2,400

1409 GIBRALTER, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2130401

1409 GIBRALTER, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
19Picture(s)
1,770Sqft
Location, Location, Location! This adorable Fully Furnished home right in Fleming Island is the perfect place to call home! Freshly painted, new carpet, newer A/C, and newer roof make this home move-in ready. Enter to cathedral ceilings, wood floors, and split bedroom floorplan.
$2,250

2309 EAGLE PERCH, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2123159

2309 EAGLE PERCH, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
42Picture(s)
1,798Sqft
This freshly painted and new bedroom floors home offers a thoughtfully designed single-story layout that balances open living with private spaces. The home features a welcoming foyer that leads into a spacious living area, perfect for both relaxing and entertaining.
$2,250

1425 LAUREL OAK, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2128647

1425 LAUREL OAK, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
21Picture(s)
1,922Sqft
Excellent location in Fleming Island, very close to elementary school and high school. Fresh interior paint and new carpet in the bedrooms.
$2,200

1488 MARSH RABBIT, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2114287

1488 MARSH RABBIT, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
35Picture(s)
1,851Sqft
Welcome to this charming 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home located in the desirable Fleming Island, FL. This house features a spacious kitchen perfect for cooking and entertaining, as well as a large family room for relaxing and spending time with loved ones.
$2,200

2035 SECRET GARDEN, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2123736

2035 SECRET GARDEN, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
32Picture(s)
2,122Sqft
Introducing our spacious 3/3.5 Condo with Garage in the highly sought-after Fleming Island, FL. This stunning home offers a comfortable and modern living space with three bedrooms and three and a half bathrooms. The open floor plan creates a seamless flow throughout the home, providing ample space for relaxation and entertaining.
$2,200

1300 PORTSIDE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003 MLS 2123659

1300 PORTSIDE, Fleming Island, Florida 32003

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
16Picture(s)
2,224Sqft
AVAILABLE NOW: SORRY, NO PETS ALLOWED.
$2,200
119 Results returned.Per Page

 

🌴 Why Live in Fleming Island, Florida?

Fleming Island is known for its beautiful neighborhoods, excellent schools, and highly convenient location. It’s one of the fastest-growing and most sought-after areas in Clay County.

 

✔ Top-Rated Schools

Home to some of the best schools in Northeast Florida, making it a top destination for families.

✔ Resort-Style Amenities

Many neighborhoods include:

  • Pools

  • Golf courses

  • Tennis courts

  • Nature trails

  • Community centers

  • Private docks

  • Walking paths

✔ Beautiful Waterfront Living

Access to:

  • Doctors Lake

  • St. Johns River

  • Multiple creeks and canals
    Waterfront and water-access homes are some of the most desirable in the region.

✔ Convenient to Jacksonville

Quick access to:

  • NAS Jax

  • Orange Park

  • Middleburg

  • Oakleaf

  • St. Johns County

  • New First Coast Expressway

✔ Shopping & Dining

Restaurants, shopping centers, specialty shops, and entertainment all within minutes.

 

🏘️ Popular Neighborhoods in Fleming Island

 

🏡 Eagle Harbor

One of the most desirable master-planned communities with golf, tennis, swimming, and exceptional amenities.

One of the largest and most popular communities in Fleming Island, Eagle Harbor features:

• Golf course homes
• Waterfront properties along Doctors Lake
• Resort-style pools, tennis courts, and parks
• Highly rated schools nearby

Perfect for families, golfers, and buyers wanting amenities close to home.

🌳 Pace Island (Gated Community)

Beautiful mature landscaping, 24/7 guard-gated entry, and lakes throughout the neighborhood.

Pace Island is a gated waterfront community offering:

• Deep water access to Doctors Lake and St. Johns River
• Private marina and docks
• Tennis courts and clubhouse
• Luxury custom homes

Ideal for boaters and buyers wanting privacy and upscale living.

🏌️ Fleming Island Plantation

Resort-style amenities, multiple pools, golf, walking trails, and family-friendly living.

Known for its beautiful landscaping and community feel, Fleming Island Plantation offers:

• Spacious single-family homes
• Golf course views
• Community pools and fitness center
• Walking trails and playgrounds

Great for buyers seeking value with lifestyle perks.

🌅 Doctors Lake Waterfront Homes

Stunning views, private docks, deep water access, and some of the most luxurious homes in Clay County. View Homes Here

🏞️ The Preserve, Harbor Island, & Other Established Areas

Quiet streets, mature trees, and well-kept communities.

Hibernia Plantation Homes for Sale

Hibernia Plantation is a newer upscale neighborhood featuring:

• Large modern homes
• Golf course living
• Resort-style pool and amenities
• Quiet, scenic setting

Popular with professionals and families looking for newer construction.

 

🏡 Types of Homes for Sale in Fleming Island

✔ Single-Family Homes

Great options for families and first-time buyers.

✔ Waterfront & Water-Access Properties

Homes with docks, lifts, and access to Doctors Lake & St. Johns River.

✔ Townhomes & Low-Maintenance Living

Ideal for downsizing or investment properties.

✔ Luxury Estates

High-end homes with premium upgrades, larger lots, and custom features.

✔ Golf Course Living

Homes in Fleming Island Plantation and Eagle Harbor.

 

📈 Fleming Island Real Estate Market Trends

Fleming Island continues to see strong demand thanks to:

  • Excellent schools

  • Resort-style amenities

  • Easy commute to Jacksonville

  • High quality of life

  • Low crime

  • Beautiful planned neighborhoods

Homes in Fleming Island often sell quickly, especially those that are updated, on the water, or located in top neighborhoods like Eagle Harbor or Pace Island.

With my construction experience, I can help you identify value, avoid costly repairs, and evaluate long-term potential.

 

🔍 Search Fleming Island Homes for Sale

Looking for:

  • Waterfront homes?

  • Homes with docks?

  • Golf course homes?

  • Homes near top schools?

  • Gated communities?

  • New construction?

I can create a custom home search tailored to your needs. Just tell me your goals.

Fleming Island FAQ’s

Is Fleming Island a good place to live?
Yes. Fleming Island is known for excellent schools, safe neighborhoods, waterfront access, golf communities, and strong home values, making it one of the most desirable areas in Clay County.

How much do homes in Fleming Island typically cost?
Home prices vary by neighborhood, size, and features such as pools or waterfront lots, but Fleming Island offers everything from affordable family homes to luxury estates.

Are there waterfront homes in Fleming Island?
Yes. Many homes are located along Doctors Lake and connected canals with private docks and boating access.

Does Fleming Island have new construction homes?
Yes. You can find both newer developments and recently built homes, along with established neighborhoods.

Is Fleming Island good for commuting to Jacksonville?
Very much so. Fleming Island offers easy access to Jacksonville, NAS Jax, Orange Park, and major highways while maintaining a quieter suburban lifestyle.

 

🛠️ Why Choose Me as Your Fleming Island REALTOR®?

With nearly two decades of real estate experience and over 20 years of construction expertise, I bring unique advantages:

✔ Construction-backed home evaluations

Spot issues before inspection.

✔ Deep local expertise in Clay County

I live and work here — I know every neighborhood’s pros, cons, and hidden gems.

✔ Skilled negotiation in competitive markets

Helping you secure the best possible deal.

✔ Award-winning service

Voted Best of Clay Real Estate Agent (2019 & 2020).

✔ Full-service seller representation

Professional photos, drone, staging guidance, marketing, and repair oversight.

 

📍 Nearby Areas I Serve

I also help clients buy and sell in:

  • Orange Park

  • Middleburg

  • Lake Asbury

  • Green Cove Springs

  • Doctors Lake waterfront

  • Eagle Harbor

  • Pace Island

  • Oakleaf Plantation

  • Jacksonville

  • St. Johns County

If you’re searching anywhere in Clay County or Northeast Florida — I can help.

 

📞 Ready to Explore Fleming Island Homes for Sale?

Let’s find the perfect home together.

Mike Schwiebert, REALTOR®
📲 Call/Text: 904-562-9345

Get More Value — No Matter Where You Move.

Picture of Mike Schwiebert

Mike Schwiebert

Mike Schwiebert is a two time Best of Clay Realtor Winner, a home selling expert, former general, building and remodeling contractor, Investor, and girl dad. 20+ years of construction experience and 18+ years of local real estate experience.