Facebook Twitter Youtube
904homestore Logo Get More Value with the Best Realtor

Kingsley Lake Waterfront Homes for Sale

If you’re searching for Kingsley Lake waterfront homes for sale, you’re looking at one of the most rare and desirable lakefront markets in Northeast Florida.

Located near Starke, Florida and within reach of Jacksonville, Kingsley Lake is famous for its perfect circular shape, crystal-clear water, and private waterfront living—making it a top choice for buyers seeking true lakefront property (not retention ponds or canals).

👉 Scroll below to view available listings, pricing trends, and everything you need to know before buying.

Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
Save Search

6189 KINGSLEY LAKE, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2136009

6189 KINGSLEY LAKE, Starke, Florida 32091

6Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
70Picture(s)
5,368Sqft
Step into timeless charm on the shores of Kingsley Lake with this one-of-a-kind lakefront retreat designed for gathering, relaxing, and making memories. The main home features 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, complemented by a private apartment above the garage offering 2 additional bedrooms and 1 bath–perfect for guests or extended family.
$2,390,000

4333 SEMINOLE, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2135058

4333 SEMINOLE, Starke, Florida 32091

2Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
29Picture(s)
2,238Sqft
Easily used as a 3-bedroom home, this beautifully designed lakefront retreat features 120 feet of prime waterfront on Kingsley Lake, prized for its limited access with no public boat ramps, helping preserve its peaceful atmosphere and crystal-clear waters. Soaring ceilings, expansive windows, and a charming cupola allow natural light to flood the open floor plan.
$1,750,000

6249 LAKE, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2114464

6249 LAKE, Starke, Florida 32091

8Bedroom(s)
5Bathroom(s)
33Picture(s)
5,617Sqft
Estate-Style Property with Two Homes, Lake Views, and Endless Potential Come and experience this unique estate-style property set on over 4 acres with stunning views of Kingsley Lake and access through the nearby Army base. Featuring two separate homes, this one-of-a-kind offering provides versatility for multi-generational living, extended family, or rental income opportunities.
$739,990

4010 BUENA VISTA, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2115496

4010 BUENA VISTA, Starke, Florida 32091

16Picture(s)
0Sqft
Experience the best of Florida lake living inside Kingsley Cove, a private gated community nestled along the pristine shores of Kingsley Lake. Known for its clear, spring-fed waters and peaceful surroundings, Kingsley Lake is one of North Florida's most sought-after destinations.
$230,000

4072 BUENA VISTA, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2082922

4072 BUENA VISTA, Starke, Florida 32091

5Picture(s)
0Sqft
Lot 61 of Kingsley Cove. when entering the gate, the lot is located on the left. This neighborhood is extremely desirable if you like Living on a lake. There is a boat ramp for the land owners of this subdivision, along with a nice sandy area to enjoy the lake. Come build your dream home on this lot and enjoy the serenity of Kingsley Lake! also see Lot 48 for sale as well.
$230,000

4042 BUENA VISTA, Starke, Florida 32091 MLS 2127647

4042 BUENA VISTA, Starke, Florida 32091

11Picture(s)
0Sqft
Build your ideal home in the gated Kingsley Cove community on desirable Lot 66. This well-positioned homesite sits just inside the entrance and offers a peaceful setting with access to Kingsley Lake amenities. Property owners enjoy the use of a private boat ramp and sandy beach area, providing easy access to boating, swimming, and lakeside relaxation.
$195,000
    6 Results returned.Per Page

    🔍 Search Kingsley Lake Waterfront Homes

    • ✔️ Real-time MLS listings
    • ✔️ Waterfront-only properties
    • ✔️ Homes with docks & lake access
    • ✔️ Updated pricing & availability

     

    🌊 Why Kingsley Lake Is One of Florida’s Best Waterfront Investments

    Kingsley Lake isn’t just another lake—it’s a high-demand, low-inventory waterfront market.

    Key Features:

    • Nearly perfect round lake (one of only a few in the U.S.)
    • Over 2,000 acres of navigable water
    • Clear, spring-fed conditions
    • Sandy shoreline (rare in Florida lakes)
    • Limited development = privacy + long-term value

    💰 Kingsley Lake Real Estate Market (2026)

    The Kingsley Lake market is tight and competitive due to limited waterfront supply.

    • Median home prices: $300K – $800K+
    • Premium waterfront homes: $700K – $1M+
    • Vacant lakefront land: Rare but highly valuable
    • Days on market: Typically longer due to niche buyers

    👉 Important:
    Unlike cookie-cutter neighborhoods, Kingsley Lake values are driven by frontage, depth, and view—not just square footage.

     

    🏠 Types of Kingsley Lake Waterfront Homes

    1. Lakefront Homes with Private Docks

    • Direct water access
    • Ideal for boating, jet skis, and fishing
    • Strong resale demand

    2. Luxury Waterfront Estates

    • Custom homes with panoramic lake views
    • Large lots and privacy
    • Perfect for second homes or high-end buyers

    3. Waterfront Lots & Buildable Land

    • Build your dream lake house
    • Limited inventory = long-term upside

    🌅 Living on Kingsley Lake (Lifestyle & Experience)

    https://a0.muscache.com/im/pictures/6a8b7838-898b-49da-9f73-343d48af5019.jpg
     
     
     
    Living on Kingsley Lake offers a completely different lifestyle than standard Florida neighborhoods:
    • Morning coffee overlooking glassy water
    • Boating, tubing, and paddleboarding
    • Fishing from your private dock
    • Quiet nights with minimal light pollution
    • No overcrowding or overdevelopment

    👉 This is “legacy property” territory—homes people keep for decades.

     

    📍 Nearby Areas to Consider

    If inventory is limited, you may also want to explore:

     

    ⚠️ What Most Buyers Don’t Know About Waterfront Homes

    Buying a lakefront home is NOT the same as buying a regular house.

    You need to understand:

    • Water depth and usability
    • Dock permits and shoreline rules
    • Septic systems vs sewer
    • Flood zones & insurance costs
    • True value of frontage

     

    👨‍💼 Work With a Kingsley Lake Waterfront Specialist

    With 20+ years of construction experience and 18+ years in Florida real estate, I help buyers:

    • Identify the best waterfront value (not just price)
    • Avoid costly mistakes with lakefront properties
    • Find off-market and coming soon listings
    • Negotiate aggressively in niche markets

     

    📲 Start Your Kingsley Lake Home Search Today

    Looking for Kingsley Lake waterfront homes for sale in Florida?

    👉 I can help you:

    • Schedule private showings
    • Set up custom MLS alerts
    • Find hidden opportunities

    Call or text: 904-562-9345
    Email: [email protected]

    ❓ FAQ 

    Is Kingsley Lake a good place to buy a waterfront home?
    Yes—Kingsley Lake is one of Florida’s most unique lakes with limited inventory and strong long-term value.

    Are there docks allowed on Kingsley Lake?
    Yes, most waterfront homes include private docks, but regulations vary.

    How deep is Kingsley Lake?
    Kingsley Lake reaches depths of around 90–100 feet, making it ideal for boating and recreation.

    How far is Kingsley Lake from Jacksonville?
    Approximately 45–60 minutes depending on location

    Call Mike Now

    🔑20+ Years in Construction and 18+ Years in Florida Real Estate 

    Photos of Kingsley Lake Waterfreont Homes for Sale
    Send Mike a Message

    I have experience that other agents simply do not have. 

    Picture of Mike Schwiebert

    Mike Schwiebert

    Mike Schwiebert is a two-time Best of Clay Realtor Winner, multiple-time Best of Jax top 5, a home selling expert, former general, building and remodeling contractor, Investor, and girl dad. 20+ years of construction experience and 18+ years of local real estate experience.