Affordable, High-Quality New Homes in St. Johns County, Florida

If you’re looking for Silverleaf new construction homes for sale, you’re exploring one of the fastest-growing, value-driven communities in St. Johns County. SilverLeaf combines affordability, modern floor plans, and smart community design — making it an excellent option for buyers who want a brand-new home without paying elite coastal premiums.

As a REALTORĀ® with 18+ years of experience and 20+ years in construction, I help buyers navigate new-build options, understand what features truly matter, and avoid costly mistakes. Whether you’re a first-time buyer, relocating, investing, or upsizing — SilverLeaf offers a balanced new-construction home solution in Northeast Florida.

Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map

155 LUCIA, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2138907

155 LUCIA, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
3Picture(s)
2,424Sqft
Sophisticated design and exceptional craftsmanship come together in The McClenaghan II by David Weekley Homes at Evergreen Island. Begin and end each day in comfort in the first-floor Owner's Retreat, featuring a spa-inspired en suite bath and a spacious walk-in closet.
$614,210

120 WEBKING HEIGHTS, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2137527

120 WEBKING HEIGHTS, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
3Picture(s)
2,395Sqft
Introducing the brand new Danielle home-part of the exclusive Executive Series in the gated community of Evergreen Island at Silverleaf. Plus, the best location in St. John's County, You will love only being 25 minutes to the beach or Mayo Clinic.
$601,670

587 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2128579

587 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
14Picture(s)
2,555Sqft
''Ready Now'' Welcome to Luxury Living The Moore Discover elegance redefined in this meticulously designed Home, at Reverie at Silverleaf. This sophisticated 2,555 sq. ft.
$599,990

138 MARIANA ISLAND, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2130357

138 MARIANA ISLAND, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
3Picture(s)
2,395Sqft
Introducing the Danielle Plan—part of the exclusive Executive Series in the gated community of Evergreen Island at Silverleaf. Plus, the best location in St. John's County, You will love only being 25 minutes to the beach or Mayo Clinic.
$589,460

104 WEBKING HEIGHTS, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2135427

104 WEBKING HEIGHTS, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
3Picture(s)
2,276Sqft
Stunning gated Evergreen Island in SilverLeaf has it all without the expense of CDD fee's! The Charlesworth elegant 2-story, beautifully designed with all of the stunning upgraded features. From the moment you step inside, you'll appreciate the open and airy feel created by 10 and 11 foot ceilings and 8-foot interior doors on the main level with owners retreat and private en-suite.
$589,260

487 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2101218

487 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
17Picture(s)
2,720Sqft
The stunning DeBary model, offers the perfect blend of luxury and practical living. This thoughtfully designed residence features three en suite bedrooms, including two primary owner's suites – ideal for multi-generational living or hosting extended family visits.
$579,990

339 BEDFORD, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2141025

339 BEDFORD, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
37Picture(s)
2,324Sqft
New Toll Brothers home, ready now! The Osprey Modern Coastal delivers the quality and craftsmanship America's Luxury Home Builder is known for, wrapped in a fresh coastal aesthetic that instantly feels like home. Step inside to a showstopping two-story foyer framed by an open railing staircase a dramatic first impression that sets the tone throughout.
$579,000

94 DAY DREAM, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2136010

94 DAY DREAM, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
20Picture(s)
2,468Sqft
Welcome to the exceptional Delmar model at Reverie at Silverleaf, where luxury meets active adult living in St. John's County's most anticipated 55+ community. This expansive residence showcases three bedrooms and a sophisticated study, perfect for those seeking both space and functionality. The thoughtfully designed 2.
$573,990

323 BEDFORD, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2136700

323 BEDFORD, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
24Picture(s)
2,324Sqft
New Toll Brothers home, ready now! The Osprey Transitional makes a statement form the movement you arrive; stone accents, transitional inspired finishes, and a soaring two story foyer set the tone. Designer luxury vinyl plan flooring carries you into a massive great room and gourmet kitchen, perfect for everyday living and effortless entertaining.
$549,000

331 BEDFORD, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2121919

331 BEDFORD, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
37Picture(s)
2,342Sqft
New Toll Brothers home, ready now! This beautifully designed home blends open-concept living with thoughtfully curated designer finishes throughout. Luxury vinyl plank flooring flows through the main living areas, creating a warm and cohesive feel.
$529,000

292 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2128575

292 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
21Picture(s)
2,029Sqft
Located in the gated active adult community of Reverie at Silverleaf, this thoughtfully designed Charlotte floor plan offers 2 bedrooms plus a flex room, 2 full baths, and a 2-car garage across 2,029 square feet of well-planned living space. This home features an Arts & Crafts exterior and serene water views.
$524,990

272 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2128577

272 KNOTTED BIRCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

2Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
13Picture(s)
1,967Sqft
Welcome to the Clark floor plan, a well-designed single-story home offering 2 bedrooms plus a flex room, 2 full baths, and a rare 3-car tandem garage, all within 1,967 square feet of comfortable living space. Scheduled for completion in February, this home features a traditional exterior and thoughtful upgrades throughout.
$519,990
52 Results returned.Per Page

🌟 Why Choose a New Home in SilverLeaf?

Ā 

āœ” Affordable Entry Into New Construction

SilverLeaf is known for offering new homes at price points usually lower than comparable communities near the coast — great value for families, first-time buyers, or investors.

āœ” Modern Floor Plans & Energy Efficiency

New builds in SilverLeaf feature up-to-date layouts, open-concept living, modern kitchens & baths, and energy-efficient construction that saves money long-term.

āœ” Growing Community in a Prime Location

Situated in St. Johns County, SilverLeaf provides easy access to major roads, schools, shopping, and conveniences. It’s also a growing area — meaning new amenities, infrastructure, and resale potential.

āœ” Low Maintenance, Peaceful Lifestyle

Because homes are new, you avoid many of the repair, maintenance, or remodeling headaches that come with older homes — offering peace of mind and future value.


Ā 

šŸ  Types of Homes Available in SilverLeaf

SilverLeaf offers a variety of new construction home types to match different needs:

  • Entry-level & starter homes — Ideal for first-time buyers or smaller families

  • Family-sized single-family homes — 3–5 bedrooms, open layouts, modern amenities

  • Energy-efficient new builds — Built to current standards for insulation, HVAC, lighting

  • Move-in ready inventory homes — For buyers needing to relocate quickly

  • Homes with modern finishes, flexible layouts, and optional upgrades

Whether you want a modest starter home or a mid-sized family home with all the upgrades, SilverLeaf offers excellent options for diverse budgets and lifestyles.


Ā 

šŸ”Ž How I Help Buyers Navigate SilverLeaf New Construction

Working with a well-informed REALTORĀ® matters — especially for new construction. Here’s how I help:

šŸ›  Construction Insight & Quality Control

With my construction background, I help you evaluate build quality, materials, layout efficiency, lot orientation, and long-term durability.

šŸ’” Upgrade & Cost Guidance

I advise on which upgrades add long-term value (e.g. structural upgrades, insulation, HVAC, layout changes) and which are less critical — helping you avoid overpaying for cosmetic extras.

šŸ§‘ā€šŸ’¼ Negotiation & Value Insight

Builders sometimes offer incentives, closing cost help, or upgrades. I help compare offers fairly — protecting your interests and ensuring you get the best deal.

šŸ“Š Resale Value & Market Perspective

I provide insight on how SilverLeaf values compare within St. Johns County, long-term appreciation potential, and future development that impacts value.

āœ… Full Representation

Because the builder pays the commission 99% of the time, you get full buyer’s agent representation — giving you protection, advice, and advocacy without additional cost.


Ā 

šŸ“ˆ Why SilverLeaf is a Smart Move Right Now

  • Increasing demand for affordable new homes in St. Johns County

  • Growing infrastructure and population expansion

  • Strong community value compared to coastal or beach-adjacent areas

  • Opportunity for equity growth as development spreads

  • Low competition compared to high-demand master-planned coastal communities

SilverLeaf gives buyers a chance to enter new construction at a budget-friendly price point — while still reaping many of the benefits of newer master-planned communities.


Ā 

šŸ“ž Ready to Explore SilverLeaf New Construction Homes?

Whether you’re a first-time buyer, moving into the area, or looking for a great value investment — I’ll help you find a new home in SilverLeaf that matches your budget and lifestyle.

Mike Schwiebert, REALTORĀ® – 904HomeStore.com
šŸ“² Call/Text: 904-562-9345
šŸ“§ Email: [email protected]

Get More Value, Start to Close — with an agent who knows construction and local markets.