Blog › Asbury Lake Homes

Real Estate Scams in Florida How to Protect Yourself When Buying or Selling a Home

šŸ” Real Estate Scams in Florida — How to Protect Yourself When Buying or Selling a Home

Real estate scams are on the rise across Florida, targeting buyers, sellers, and renters with sophisticated schemes that can fool even experienced investors. According to the FBI, nearly 10,000 Americans fell victim to real estate fraud in 2024, losing more than $173 million. Unfortunately, Florida remains one of the nation’s hotspots for wire fraud and title theft due to its active housing market and large number of remote closings.

As a Northeast Florida REALTORĀ® serving Clay County, Jacksonville, Orange Park, and St. Johns, I’ve seen firsthand how criminals exploit technology, fake listings, and wire transfer tricks to steal money and property. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, awareness and verification are your best defenses.


āš ļø Wire Transfer Fraud — The #1 Real Estate Scam in Florida

This scam typically strikes right before closing. Hackers spoof emails from real estate agents, lenders, or title companies, sending fake wiring instructions that redirect your closing funds into fraudulent accounts.
Losses average over $70,000 per victim, and most funds are never recovered.

Red flags include:

  • Sudden changes to wiring instructions or new ā€œurgentā€ emails
  • Slightly altered email domains (e.g., ā€œtitlle-co.comā€)
  • Pressure to send funds immediately to avoid delays

Protect yourself:
Always verify wiring instructions by phone using a verified number—never by replying to an email. As your trusted local agent, I personally confirm closing details directly with title companies to safeguard my clients.


šŸ  Rental Scams and Fake Listings

Rental listing scams are common across Jacksonville, Orange Park, and Fleming Island, where high demand makes renters more vulnerable. Fraudsters copy real listings or advertise fake ones at below-market rents, demanding deposits upfront for properties that don’t exist.

Watch for:

  • Prices that seem too good to be true
  • Landlords who can’t meet in person or claim to be overseas
  • Requests for wire transfers or payment via gift cards

Always verify ownership through county property records and view the property in person before paying. Homeowners should also monitor for fake rental listings using their addresses.


🧾 Title and Deed Fraud — Stealing Homes in Broad Daylight

Title theft occurs when criminals forge signatures on quitclaim deeds to ā€œtransferā€ your home into their name. Vacant or investment properties are prime targets. In Florida, title fraud cases have increased sharply as more transactions occur remotely.

Warning signs include:

  • Unexpected mortgage notices or tax bills stopping
  • Deed transfers you didn’t authorize
  • Foreclosure notices for loans you never took

Check your county’s Property Fraud Alert program if they have one, and monitor public records. Title insurance offers extra protection.


šŸ‘¤ Fake Buyers, Sellers, and REALTORSĀ®

Scammers now impersonate legitimate REALTORSĀ® and property owners to trick unsuspecting victims. In one South Floridacase, a scammer stole a real agent’s identity and collected thousands in fake fees.

Before working with anyone:

  • Verify real estate licenses through Florida DBPR
  • Ask to meet in person or over video
  • Confirm ownership via county records

As a licensed Florida REALTORĀ® (Mike Schwiebert, INI Realty), I always provide verifiable credentials, references, and transparent communication—something scammers never do.


šŸ’° Bait-and-Switch & ā€œWe Buy Housesā€ Schemes

Some ā€œcash buyersā€ or online investors lure sellers with inflated offers, then renegotiate last-minute or assign contracts for profit—leaving the seller with far less than market value. Always consult an experienced REALTORĀ® before accepting quick-cash deals.


āœ… How to Protect Yourself in Florida Real Estate Transactions

  1. Work with verified professionals. Choose licensed Florida REALTORSĀ®, attorneys, and title companies.
  2. Confirm all identities via official channels and photo ID.
  3. Secure your information. Use strong passwords and two-factor authentication.
  4. Never rush. Scammers create urgency—slow down and verify.
  5. Use trusted payment methods. Never send funds without voice confirmation.
  6. Monitor your property through local fraud alert systems.
  7. Report fraud immediately to law enforcement and the FBI’s IC3.

šŸ” The Bottom Line

Real estate scams in Florida are becoming more advanced, but with proper guidance, you can stay safe. Trust experience, not urgency.
If you’re planning to buy or sell a home in Northeast Florida, I’ll help you navigate every step securely—verifying documents, coordinating with trusted title companies, and protecting your investment.

šŸ“ž Contact Mike Schwiebert, REALTORĀ®
904HomeStore.com | 904-562-9345
Serving Clay County, Lake Asbury, Jacksonville, and St. Johns County

Your home is one of your biggest investments—let’s make sure it’s protected.

  1. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center – https://www.ic3.gov/AnnualReport/Reports/2024_IC3Report.pdf
  2. National Cybersecurity Alliance – https://staysafeonline.org/resources/5-common-real-estate-scams-you-need-to-know-about/
  3. Rocket Mortgage – https://www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/real-estate-scams
  4. Eftsure – https://www.eftsure.com/articles/wire-fraud-statistics/
  5. National Association of REALTORSĀ® – https://www.nar.realtor/wire-fraud
  6. MMBB – https://www.mmbb.org/article/unmasking-real-estate-scams/
  7. Federal Trade Commission – https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/rental-listing-scams
  8. Florida REALTORSĀ® – https://www.floridarealtors.org/news-media/news-articles/2025/06/quitclaim-deed-fraud-rise-fbi-says
  9. American Land Title Association – https://www.alta.org/news/news.cfm?20231108-Over-Half-of-US-Real-Estate-Professionals-Experienced-a-Seller-Impersonation-Fraud-Attempt-in-2023
  10. NBC Washington – https://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/scammers-impersonating-owners-in-vacant-land-sales/
  11. Kiplinger – https://www.kiplinger.com/article/real-estate/t048-c050-s002-how-to-protect-your-home-from-deed-theft.html
  12. Federal Housing Finance Agency – https://www.fhfa.gov/AboutUs/Reports/ReportDocuments/FraudPrevention.pdf
  13. NBC Miami – https://www.nbcmiami.com/investigations/scammer-posing-as-realtor-costs-victims-thousands-and-unfairly-tarnishes-a-reputation/3598591/

Filed under Asbury Lake Homes, Best in Clay Realtor 2019, Best In Clay Realtor 2020, Best of Clay County Fl Real Estate Agent Realtor. Tags: Home Scams and How to avoid them

Mike Schwiebert

Work with Mike

Mike Schwiebert, REALTORĀ®

INI Realty INC

Get More Valueā„¢

Why work with Mike

  • 18+ years as a Florida REALTORĀ®
  • 20+ years of construction experience as a remodeler, builder and general contractor: he knows what repairs need to be done, and what may help you Get More Value
  • Voted Best of Clay 2019 and 2020
  • Lake Asbury resident since 2009
  • Free use of his moving trailer or dump trailer when you buy or sell with Mike

Complimentary trailer use for clients buying or selling with Mike Schwiebert, INI Realty INC. Subject to availability; terms apply.