Keystone Heights Homes for Sale

🏡 Keystone Heights, FL Homes for Sale

Small-Town Charm, Lakeside Living & Outdoor Lifestyle in Clay County

Welcome to Keystone Heights, Florida — a peaceful, nature-rich community offering lakefront living, spacious lots, and a relaxed small-town atmosphere. Nestled in southwest Clay County, Keystone Heights is known for its spring-fed lakes, rolling terrain, rural feel, and friendly community vibe, making it a perfect escape from busy city life — while still within commuting distance to Jacksonville, Gainesville, and Middleburg. You will love Keystone Heights Homes and the variety of styles and lakefront living.

If you’re looking for affordable lakefront property, room to breathe, and a true Old-Florida lifestyle, Keystone Heights may be the perfect place to call home. See more details below.

Sort Option
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map
Save Search

6928 GILDA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2104272

6928 GILDA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
32Picture(s)
2,310Sqft
Welcome to your storybook retreat in Keystone Heights! This spacious 4BR/2BA double-wide (2,310 sq ft) rests on 5 acres of gated, partly fenced land—perfect for peaceful country living with room to roam. Recently refreshed, it boasts a brand-new roof (damaged plywood replaced),. With new gutters, plush carpet, and glowing LED lights throughout.
$349,000

5687 CIBOLA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2116975

5687 CIBOLA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
22Picture(s)
1,515Sqft
Welcome to your brand-new home in the heart of Keystone Heights. Nestled on an oversized 1.1 acre lot, this new construction home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing ample space for your family and lifestyle. Step inside to an inviting open-concept layout that's perfect for both everyday living and entertaining.
$345,000

5192 CR-214, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2115826

5192 CR-214, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
26Picture(s)
2,000Sqft
Don't miss your chance to own your dream home on a spacious 0.62-acre lot with plenty of room to grow! This stunning new construction offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a dedicated office, dining room, and a 2-car garage—perfect for modern living. The gourmet kitchen features 42'' soft-close shaker cabinets and quartz countertops, ideal for cooking and entertaining.
$344,000

6012 INDIAN, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2117360

6012 INDIAN, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
61Picture(s)
2,126Sqft
Welcome home to this beautiful four BR, three BA home on five acres! Over 2100 SF of tape and texture walls with knockdown ceilings. Tray ceiling in living room and blinds on all windows. Custom front (8x10) and back (12x24) decks with solar lights on posts. New well and septic when the home was installed. Open kitchen, dining and living rooms. Split bedroom plan with deluxe primary suite.
$339,900

5683 SILVER SANDS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2078434

5683 SILVER SANDS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
39Picture(s)
1,333Sqft
***OWNER FINANCING AVAILABLE 5.9% IF QUALIFIED, AND MONEY TOWARDS BUYER'S CLOSING COSTS***HIGH QUALITY NEW CONSTRUCTION with the builder's PERSONAL CUSTOM DESIGN throughout!! This BEAUTIFUL HOME is COMPLETE and ready to go!! If you are looking for a quality new home with modern designs and upgrades, look no further.
$334,000

5891 SEQUOIA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2117789

5891 SEQUOIA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
53Picture(s)
2,052Sqft
Spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bath home offering over 2,000 sq ft of living space on a sprawling 2.25-acre lot in Big Tree Lakes. Built in 2007 and featuring a brand-new 2025 roof, and 2024 HVAC, this property provides tremendous opportunity. Parcel includes two lots of record as well.
$330,000

6266 LITTLE LAKE GENEVA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2085450

6266 LITTLE LAKE GENEVA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
20Picture(s)
1,515Sqft
Don't miss this opportunity to own your dream home on a generous lot with room to grow! Nestled on a .6 acre lot, this move-in ready, new construction home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing ample space for your family and lifestyle. Enjoy the benefits an open concept floor plan and modern finishes.
$322,500

4842 2ND, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2100810

4842 2ND, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
40Picture(s)
2,381Sqft
Live the good life in this beautifully maintained, move-in ready brick home in the desirable Hidden Hills community of Keystone Heights. You'll have peace of mind with your brand new HVAC, newer roof, new water heater and recently pumped septic. Best of all, there's no HOA so the options are endless.
$315,000

4500 BONDARENKO, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2106842

4500 BONDARENKO, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
27Picture(s)
1,344Sqft
Welcome to your own private slice of paradise! Nestled on 6.26 acres of serene countryside, this adorable 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, charm, and country living. This home is ideal for anyone seeking peace, privacy, and the simple joys of nature.
$310,000

7861 STATE ROAD 21, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2103960

7861 STATE ROAD 21, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
1Bathroom(s)
51Picture(s)
1,220Sqft
Discover the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and natural beauty with this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath waterfront home located in-town near recreation, shopping, and schools. Ideal for a starter home, retirement retreat, or weekend getaway, this property offers an airy, open floor plan with cathedral ceilings that create a bright and inviting atmosphere.
$299,999

220 GROVE, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2108349

220 GROVE, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)
2Bathroom(s)
41Picture(s)
1,560Sqft
Welcome to this well maintained and updated pool home near downtown Keystone Heights and the schools! Fully updated kitchen, large laundry room and flex room that can be used as a game room or fourth bedroom (has walk in closet). No carpet, the flooring is LVP and ceramic tile. Screen enclosed pool in the private back yard.
$299,900

5671 CHUGAH, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2100550

5671 CHUGAH, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
47Picture(s)
1,828Sqft
So much space and potential in this updated 3/3 home with back screen porch, carport and detached garage. This home consists of a large, open kitchen with breakfast nook. Two spaces for living or family rooms and a third flex space with double sided fireplace that could be made into an office or fourth bedroom and three full bathrooms.
$299,900
66 Results returned.Per Page

🌟 Why Buyers Love Keystone Heights Homes

  • Beautiful spring-fed lakes & waterfront homes

  • Larger lots & acreage properties

  • Peaceful country lifestyle with charming downtown

  • Boating, kayaking, fishing & nature everywhere

  • Quick drive to Middleburg, Gainesville & Starke

  • Close-knit, community-focused living

  • Lower property taxes and strong affordability

Keystone Heights offers small-town Florida living with big outdoor adventure.

🏠 Homes in Keystone Heights

You’ll find a wide range of housing styles and land options, including:

  • Lakefront homes on Lake Geneva, Lake Brooklyn & more

  • Homes with acreage & wooded lots

  • Country estates & ranch homes

  • Modern builds & remodeled homes

  • Manufactured & modular homes on land

  • New construction opportunities

  • Affordable starter homes & investment options

Whether you’re seeking a homestead, a lakefront retreat, or peaceful rural living, Keystone Heights delivers.

🌳 Lifestyle & Amenities

Life in Keystone Heights centers around outdoor living, nature, and community, including:

  • Parks & lakefront beaches

  • Community golf course

  • Public boat ramps & fishing areas

  • Hiking, horseback riding & bike trails

  • Camp Blanding & vast natural preserves nearby

  • Sports and recreation at Keystone Beach & city parks

This is North Florida living at its purest — quiet, scenic, and full of open skies.

🏫 Schools & Area Services

Served by the Clay County School District, Keystone Heights offers:

  • Keystone Heights Elementary

  • Keystone Heights Jr/Sr High School

  • Nearby private & charter school options

  • Local library, community center & city services

A charming small-town setting with supportive community values.

🧭 Local Real Estate Expert Advantage

As a Clay County Realtor®, Lake Asbury resident, and former custom builder, I help you:

✅ Compare acreage, lakefront & neighborhood options
✅ Understand well/septic systems & rural utilities
✅ Evaluate construction quality & renovation potential
✅ Identify future growth & value opportunities
✅ Secure land for new builds or homesteads

Whether you’re relocating, retiring, investing, or looking for quiet country-lake living, I’ve got Keystone Heights covered.

🔎 Start Your Keystone Heights Home Search

Let’s find the perfect home or lakefront property:

📲 Call/Text: 904-562-9345
🌐 Search Keystone Heights Homes: 904HomeStore.com

Tell me what you’re looking for — I’ll curate a custom list just for you.

 

Voted Best Real Estate Agent 2019 in Clay County!

 

  • Keystone Heights FL homes for sale

  • Keystone Heights real estate

  • Lakefront homes Keystone Heights FL

  • Keystone Heights land & acreage

  • Clay County rural homes

  • Lake Geneva homes for sale FL

  • North Florida country living