🏡 Keystone Heights, FL Homes for Sale

Small-Town Charm, Lakeside Living & Outdoor Lifestyle in Clay County

Welcome to Keystone Heights, Florida — a peaceful, nature-rich community offering lakefront living, spacious lots, and a relaxed small-town atmosphere. Nestled in southwest Clay County, Keystone Heights is known for its spring-fed lakes, rolling terrain, rural feel, and friendly community vibe, making it a perfect escape from busy city life — while still within commuting distance to Jacksonville, Gainesville, and Middleburg. You will love Keystone Heights Homes and the variety of styles and lakefront living.

If you’re looking for affordable lakefront property, room to breathe, and a true Old-Florida lifestyle, Keystone Heights may be the perfect place to call home. See more details below.

 

All

For sale

For Rent

Sort by:

• Price Descending
• Newest
• Bedrooms
• Featured

Price DescendingPrice AscendingNewestOldestBedrooms descendingBedrooms ascendingFeatured descendingFeatured ascending

Grid

List

Map

Save Search

More Details

5294 COUNTY ROAD 352, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2119054

5294 COUNTY ROAD 352, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

23Picture(s)

1,512Sqft

Don't miss this opportunity own your dream home on a generous lot with room to grow! Nestled on 1 acre lot, this move-in ready new construction home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing ample space for your family and lifestyle. Enjoy the benefits of a split floor plan and modern finishes.

$329,900

More Details

4730 3RD, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2125982

4730 3RD, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

20Picture(s)

1,515Sqft

Welcome to your brand-new MOVE IN READY home in the heart of Keystone Heights. Nestled on a .6 acre lot, this MOVE IN READY new construction home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing ample space for your family and lifestyle. Step inside to an inviting open-concept layout that's perfect for both everyday living and entertaining.

$328,500

More Details

7596 SILVER SANDS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2124515

7596 SILVER SANDS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

26Picture(s)

1,659Sqft

Don't miss this opportunity own your dream home on a generous lot with room to grow! This MOVE IN READY home offers 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing ample space for your family and lifestyle. Enjoy the benefits of a split floor plan and modern finishes.

$325,000

More Details

360 NIGHTINGALE, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2128900

360 NIGHTINGALE, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

4Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

62Picture(s)

2,175Sqft

Nearly half acre brick home with metal roof & room for your toys! This property offers long term durability and value with a metal roof and low maintenance brick exterior. Inside, you will find a functional and comfortable layout ideal for everyday living and entertaining.

$320,000

More Details

6266 LITTLE LAKE GENEVA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2085450

6266 LITTLE LAKE GENEVA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

20Picture(s)

1,515Sqft

Don't miss this opportunity to own your dream home on a generous lot with room to grow! Nestled on a .6 acre lot, this move-in ready, new construction home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing ample space for your family and lifestyle. Enjoy the benefits an open concept floor plan and modern finishes.

$315,000

More Details

0 NELSONS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2124273

0 NELSONS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

34Picture(s)

1,375.60Sqft

Seller to offer closing cost assistance to Buyer! Another gorgeous W T Construction new-construction home is underway in a uniquely beautiful community in the heart of Keystone Heights. The Paul Plan offers an affordable opportunity without sacrificing the exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail that sets W T Construction apart.

$314,900

More Details

0 NELSONS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2124154

0 NELSONS, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

34Picture(s)

1,375.60Sqft

Another gorgeous W T Construction new-construction home is underway in a uniquely beautiful community in the heart of Keystone Heights. The Paul Plan offers an affordable opportunity without sacrificing the exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail that sets W T Construction apart. This 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is situated on a lovely lot with a peaceful country feel.

$314,900

More Details

4500 BONDARENKO, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2106842

4500 BONDARENKO, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

27Picture(s)

1,344Sqft

*Seller offering $3,500 to buyer concessions* Welcome to your own private slice of paradise! Nestled on 6.26 acres of serene countryside, this adorable 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, charm, and country living. This home is ideal for anyone seeking peace, privacy, and the simple joys of nature.

$307,000

More Details

6276 MAGNOLIA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2123026

6276 MAGNOLIA, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

45Picture(s)

1,120Sqft

Well maintained brick home nestled in Postmasters Village with access to private Lake Hutchinson. Original home was a 2/1 with attached garage. The garage has been converted to a primary suite with full bath. Off the living room is a Florida room which could serve as a fourth bedroom. There is an attached one car carport and a large detached garage/workshop on the adjoining lot.

$299,900

More Details

7861 STATE ROAD 21, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2103960

7861 STATE ROAD 21, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

1Bathroom(s)

51Picture(s)

1,220Sqft

Discover the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and natural beauty with this 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath waterfront home located in-town near recreation, shopping, and schools. Ideal for a starter home, retirement retreat, or weekend getaway, this property offers an airy, open floor plan with cathedral ceilings that create a bright and inviting atmosphere.

$297,500

More Details

7157 WESLEYAN, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2128573

7157 WESLEYAN, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

3Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

51Picture(s)

1,380Sqft

**NO HOA**NEW BUILD**HUGE LOT** This BRAND NEW 2025 HOME by a CUSTOM BUILDER (will consider all buyer requests) offers a rare opportunity to own a high-quality, private retreat with NO HOA. Constructed with durable Hardie lap siding, this home sits on over 1/3rd of an acre, providing plenty of room for you to bring outdoor toys.

$295,000

More Details

420 PALMETTO, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656 MLS 2121089

420 PALMETTO, Keystone Heights, Florida 32656

2Bedroom(s)

2Bathroom(s)

46Picture(s)

1,686Sqft

Discover quiet downtown living in the heart of Keystone Heights with this charming 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom home, perfectly located near multiple parks featuring tennis courts, basketball courts, playgrounds, and just minutes from the Keystone Beach. Enjoy a golf-cart-friendly community with convenience and recreation at every turn.

$289,900

• Previous
• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4
• 5
• 6
• Next

68 Results returned.Per Page 612182430100

🌟 Why Buyers Love Keystone Heights Homes

• Beautiful spring-fed lakes & waterfront homes

• Larger lots & acreage properties

• Peaceful country lifestyle with charming downtown

• Boating, kayaking, fishing & nature everywhere

• Quick drive to Middleburg, Gainesville & Starke

• Close-knit, community-focused living

• Lower property taxes and strong affordability

Keystone Heights offers small-town Florida living with big outdoor adventure.

🏠 Homes in Keystone Heights

You’ll find a wide range of housing styles and land options, including:

• Lakefront homes on Lake Geneva, Lake Brooklyn & more

• Homes with acreage & wooded lots

• Country estates & ranch homes

• Modern builds & remodeled homes

• Manufactured & modular homes on land

• New construction opportunities

• Affordable starter homes & investment options

Whether you’re seeking a homestead, a lakefront retreat, or peaceful rural living, Keystone Heights delivers.

🌳 Lifestyle & Amenities

Life in Keystone Heights centers around outdoor living, nature, and community, including:

• Parks & lakefront beaches

• Community golf course

• Public boat ramps & fishing areas

• Hiking, horseback riding & bike trails

• Camp Blanding & vast natural preserves nearby

• Sports and recreation at Keystone Beach & city parks

This is North Florida living at its purest — quiet, scenic, and full of open skies.

🏫 Schools & Area Services

Served by the Clay County School District, Keystone Heights offers:

• Keystone Heights Elementary

• Keystone Heights Jr/Sr High School

• Nearby private & charter school options

• Local library, community center & city services

A charming small-town setting with supportive community values.

🧭 Local Real Estate Expert Advantage

As a Clay County Realtor®, Lake Asbury resident, and former custom builder, I help you:

✅ Compare acreage, lakefront & neighborhood options
✅ Understand well/septic systems & rural utilities
✅ Evaluate construction quality & renovation potential
✅ Identify future growth & value opportunities
✅ Secure land for new builds or homesteads

Whether you’re relocating, retiring, investing, or looking for quiet country-lake living, I’ve got Keystone Heights covered.

🔎 Start Your Keystone Heights Home Search

Let’s find the perfect home or lakefront property:

📲 Call/Text: 904-562-9345
🌐 Search Keystone Heights Homes: 904HomeStore.com

Tell me what you’re looking for — I’ll curate a custom list just for you.