Affordable, High-Quality New Homes in St. Johns County, Florida

If you’re looking for Silverleaf new construction homes for sale, you’re exploring one of the fastest-growing, value-driven communities in St. Johns County. SilverLeaf combines affordability, modern floor plans, and smart community design — making it an excellent option for buyers who want a brand-new home without paying elite coastal premiums.

As a REALTORĀ® with 18+ years of experience and 20+ years in construction, I help buyers navigate new-build options, understand what features truly matter, and avoid costly mistakes. Whether you’re a first-time buyer, relocating, investing, or upsizing — SilverLeaf offers a balanced new-construction home solution in Northeast Florida.

Sort by:
  • Price Descending
  • Newest
  • Bedrooms
  • Featured
Grid
List
Map

37 COURTNEY OAKS, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2141333

37 COURTNEY OAKS, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

5Bedroom(s)
5Bathroom(s)
59Picture(s)
3,991Sqft
Our stunning Stella II model in Courtney Oaks is now for sale with a 90 day delayed close with NO leaseback. The home is situated on a large water to preserve view homesite. This home has it all, 4 bedrooms, 5 baths, insulated 3 car split garage, downstairs recreation room, upstairs bonus and loft, study and formal dining room.
$1,699,900

148 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2137623

148 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

5Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
21Picture(s)
3,996Sqft
Discover this ''Kasie'' new construction home by MasterCraft Builder Group, nestled in the gated Hidden Creek neighborhood at John's Island within the no-CDD Silverleaf community. This 2-story home offers a sought-after 4-car garage, spacious owner's suite with large shower and freestanding tub, secondary bedroom with a full bath on the main floor, pool bath, and pocket office.
$1,385,900

23 PINE GROVE, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2130938

23 PINE GROVE, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

3Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
23Picture(s)
3,508Sqft
Exceptional ''Cameron'' new-construction single-story POOL HOME on a coveted corner homesite, crafted by Mastercraft Builder Group within the gated enclave of Courtney Oaks at Silverleaf. Offering 3,508 square feet of refined living, this home features four bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths, a private study, formal dining room, and an impressive four-car courtyard-entry garage.
$1,330,900

233 ARBOR CREEK, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2137609

233 ARBOR CREEK, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

5Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
22Picture(s)
4,055Sqft
Discover the ''Harper'' new construction home by MasterCraft Builder Group, nestled in the gated Hidden Creek neighborhood at John's Island within the no-CDD Silverleaf community. This two-story home offers a spacious owner's suite and secondary bedroom with a full bath on the main floor, plus a versatile flex room/office, pool bath, and pocket office.
$1,314,900

108 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2134632

108 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

5Bedroom(s)
5Bathroom(s)
26Picture(s)
4,757Sqft
Southern Farmhouse elegance meets modern luxury in this stunning 4,757-SF new construction home by MasterCraft Builder Group, located in the gated Hidden Creek enclave of Silverleaf. A grand foyer and dramatic two-story family room with soaring ceilings and transom windows fill the open-concept living spaces with abundant natural light.
$1,308,900

14 RIVER BRANCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2129337

14 RIVER BRANCH, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

5Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
26Picture(s)
4,055Sqft
Experience elevated design in the ''Harper'' Farmhouse by MasterCraft Builder Group, located in the gated, NO-CDD enclave of Courtney Oaks at Silverleaf. Situated on an expansive corner lot with room for a future pool, this thoughtfully designed home offers a 3-car garage, mudroom, pool bath, pocket office, enclosed study, and a generous upstairs bonus room.
$1,209,900

38 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2124883

38 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
21Picture(s)
3,311Sqft
Experience elevated living in this stunning Carson floorplan new construction by MasterCraft Builder Group, located within the gated Hidden Creek enclave of Silverleaf- with no CDD fees. This thoughtfully designed single-story home features soaring 12' ceilings and transom windows throughout the main living areas, filling the open layout with natural light.
$1,177,900

128 ARBOR CREEK, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2130749

128 ARBOR CREEK, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
18Picture(s)
3,164Sqft
Discover refined Southern elegance in the ''Ella'' 4-bedroom, 4-bath residence by Mastercraft Builder Group in the gated NO CDD community of Hidden Creek at Silverleaf. Soaring 12-foot ceilings and stacked transom windows bathe the main living spaces in natural light, enhancing the home's open, sophisticated ambiance.
$1,168,900

95 IRVINGTON, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2135093

95 IRVINGTON, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

5Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
24Picture(s)
4,518Sqft
Experience luxury living in this stunning Toll Brothers 5 bedroom, 4.5 bath home nestled in the gated community of Newbrook.
$1,149,000

210 ARBOR CREEK, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2101108

210 ARBOR CREEK, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
4Bathroom(s)
52Picture(s)
3,164Sqft
Indulge in refined living with this exquisite new construction POOL HOME by MasterCraft Builder Group, set within the exclusive, gated Hidden Creek enclave of John's Island in the no-CDD Silverleaf community. This one-story Southern Farmhouse masterpiece offers 4 spacious bedrooms, 4 luxurious baths, and a private pocket office plus flex room.
$1,124,900

523 BROOK RIDGE, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2111336

523 BROOK RIDGE, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
32Picture(s)
3,111Sqft
Discover the Costa Mesa II – a thoughtfully designed floor plan that balances open-concept living with private retreats, perfect for families of all sizes. With 3,047 square feet of comfortable and customizable space, this home invites you to live both freely and luxuriously. Imagine stepping through the front door into a spacious foyer that guides you effortlessly into the heart of the home.
$1,074,825

160 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092 MLS 2138845

160 BLUE RIVER, St. Augustine, Florida 32092

4Bedroom(s)
3Bathroom(s)
19Picture(s)
2,860Sqft
Discover the ''Tanner'' new construction home by MasterCraft Builder Group, nestled in the gated Hidden Creek neighborhood at John's Island within the no-CDD Silverleaf community. This beautifully designed one-story coastal-style home offers 2,860 square feet of effortless living with 4 bedrooms, 3-bathrooms, and an open, airy layout enhanced by a neutral color palette.
$1,061,900
52 Results returned.Per Page

🌟 Why Choose a New Home in SilverLeaf?

Ā 

āœ” Affordable Entry Into New Construction

SilverLeaf is known for offering new homes at price points usually lower than comparable communities near the coast — great value for families, first-time buyers, or investors.

āœ” Modern Floor Plans & Energy Efficiency

New builds in SilverLeaf feature up-to-date layouts, open-concept living, modern kitchens & baths, and energy-efficient construction that saves money long-term.

āœ” Growing Community in a Prime Location

Situated in St. Johns County, SilverLeaf provides easy access to major roads, schools, shopping, and conveniences. It’s also a growing area — meaning new amenities, infrastructure, and resale potential.

āœ” Low Maintenance, Peaceful Lifestyle

Because homes are new, you avoid many of the repair, maintenance, or remodeling headaches that come with older homes — offering peace of mind and future value.


Ā 

šŸ  Types of Homes Available in SilverLeaf

SilverLeaf offers a variety of new construction home types to match different needs:

  • Entry-level & starter homes — Ideal for first-time buyers or smaller families

  • Family-sized single-family homes — 3–5 bedrooms, open layouts, modern amenities

  • Energy-efficient new builds — Built to current standards for insulation, HVAC, lighting

  • Move-in ready inventory homes — For buyers needing to relocate quickly

  • Homes with modern finishes, flexible layouts, and optional upgrades

Whether you want a modest starter home or a mid-sized family home with all the upgrades, SilverLeaf offers excellent options for diverse budgets and lifestyles.


Ā 

šŸ”Ž How I Help Buyers Navigate SilverLeaf New Construction

Working with a well-informed REALTORĀ® matters — especially for new construction. Here’s how I help:

šŸ›  Construction Insight & Quality Control

With my construction background, I help you evaluate build quality, materials, layout efficiency, lot orientation, and long-term durability.

šŸ’” Upgrade & Cost Guidance

I advise on which upgrades add long-term value (e.g. structural upgrades, insulation, HVAC, layout changes) and which are less critical — helping you avoid overpaying for cosmetic extras.

šŸ§‘ā€šŸ’¼ Negotiation & Value Insight

Builders sometimes offer incentives, closing cost help, or upgrades. I help compare offers fairly — protecting your interests and ensuring you get the best deal.

šŸ“Š Resale Value & Market Perspective

I provide insight on how SilverLeaf values compare within St. Johns County, long-term appreciation potential, and future development that impacts value.

āœ… Full Representation

Because the builder pays the commission 99% of the time, you get full buyer’s agent representation — giving you protection, advice, and advocacy without additional cost.


Ā 

šŸ“ˆ Why SilverLeaf is a Smart Move Right Now

  • Increasing demand for affordable new homes in St. Johns County

  • Growing infrastructure and population expansion

  • Strong community value compared to coastal or beach-adjacent areas

  • Opportunity for equity growth as development spreads

  • Low competition compared to high-demand master-planned coastal communities

SilverLeaf gives buyers a chance to enter new construction at a budget-friendly price point — while still reaping many of the benefits of newer master-planned communities.


Ā 

šŸ“ž Ready to Explore SilverLeaf New Construction Homes?

Whether you’re a first-time buyer, moving into the area, or looking for a great value investment — I’ll help you find a new home in SilverLeaf that matches your budget and lifestyle.

Mike Schwiebert, REALTORĀ® – 904HomeStore.com
šŸ“² Call/Text: 904-562-9345
šŸ“§ Email: [email protected]

Get More Value, Start to Close — with an agent who knows construction and local markets.