Neighborhoods › St. Johns County › Stillwater

Stillwater homes for sale in St. Johns County

Stillwater homes for sale are in St. Johns County, Florida, with ZIP code 32259. About 100 homes have sold or been listed here in the last two years. Stillwater real estate includes mostly single-family homes, along with a few townhomes.

Most homes are new construction, built from 2021 to 2026, with most built since 2024. Homes generally have 2 to 3 bedrooms and about 1,500 to 2,250 square feet on lots of about 0.13 acres. Most homes for sale are one-story. Lennar is building in Stillwater now. Stillwater is listed as a 55+ active adult community in the local MLS.

27 homes for sale in Stillwater

See them on the map

Builders building in Stillwater now

  • Lennar

Named in the descriptions of new homes for sale here, from the local MLS.

Don't be stuck without representation.

Register before you visit a model home

If you visit a builder before an agent registers you, you are usually stuck without your own representation for that home - most builders won't let you add an agent later. The builder's sales team works for the builder, not for you. Let Mike register you before your first visit, so someone is looking out for your best interest from day one.

Register me before I visit

Register me with the builder

Mike registers you with the builder before your first visit, so you have your own agent from day one.

A phone number or an email is enough. Your details go only to this agent. They are never sold or shared. Privacy policy

Book a video tour

Can't get there yet? Mike can walk a model or a home for you on a live video call.

A phone number or an email is enough. Your details go only to this agent. They are never sold or shared. Privacy policy

More near Stillwater

Mike Schwiebert

Your Stillwater Real Estate Agent

Mike Schwiebert, REALTOR®

INI Realty INC

Get More Value™

Why work with Mike

  • 18+ years as a Florida REALTOR®
  • 20+ years of construction experience as a remodeler, builder and general contractor: he knows what repairs need to be done, and what may help you Get More Value
  • Voted Best of Clay 2019 and 2020
  • Lake Asbury resident since 2009
  • Free use of his moving trailer or dump trailer when you buy or sell with Mike

Complimentary trailer use for clients buying or selling with Mike Schwiebert, INI Realty INC. Subject to availability; terms apply.

Questions about Stillwater

Who is the best REALTOR® in Stillwater?

Mike Schwiebert is a REALTOR® with INI Realty INC serving Stillwater. Licensed since 2007. Voted Best of Clay 2019 and 2020 (Clay Today). Voted Best of Jax Top 5 2019 (Folio). Lake Asbury resident since 2009. Client reviews on Google, Facebook, Zillow and Realtor.com. Call or text 904-562-9345. See Mike's track record.

What are the homes like in Stillwater?

Most are single-family homes, with a few townhomes. Homes generally have 2 to 3 bedrooms and about 1,500 to 2,250 square feet.

Is Stillwater new construction?

Most homes are new construction, built from 2021 to 2026, with most built since 2024.

Does Stillwater have an HOA?

Homes in Stillwater have an HOA.

What amenities does Stillwater have?

Amenities most listings name include a clubhouse, fitness center, gated access, golf course, maintenance grounds, tennis court(s), pickleball, and sidewalks.

Is Stillwater a 55+ community?

Stillwater is listed as a 55+ active adult community in the local MLS. Each community sets its own age and residency rules, so confirm them with the community or its homeowners association before you buy.

What extras does Mike offer buyers and sellers?

Mike lists these for clients: 18+ years as a Florida REALTOR®; 20+ years of construction experience as a remodeler, builder and general contractor: he knows what repairs need to be done, and what may help you Get More Value; Voted Best of Clay 2019 and 2020; Lake Asbury resident since 2009; Free use of his moving trailer or dump trailer when you buy or sell with Mike. Complimentary trailer use for clients buying or selling with Mike Schwiebert, INI Realty INC. Subject to availability; terms apply.

Thinking of selling in Stillwater?

Mike can tell you what your Stillwater home is worth. Get your home value.